The Police Can Legally Kick You Out of Your Home
Police officers are accused of violating the First, Second, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments all the time, but even the most ardent civil libertarians tend to forget that the Third Amendment exists. So it’s surprising that a lawsuit filed by a family in Hendersonville, Nevada, last week alleges that police broke into their two houses back in July 2011 in violation of their constitutional rights not to be forced to quarter soldiers in their homes.
Anthony Mitchell claims he refused SWAT officers’ request to use his home in order to observe a domestic abuse standoff, but the cops forced their way inside his house anyway, pepper-spraying him and his dog. The lawsuit further alleges that Anthony’s parents, Michael and Linda, were treated roughly and forced from their home. Michael and Anthony were arrested for obstructing justice (these charges were later dismissed), and the family is suing the officers involved and the department in Las Vegas on various charges, including violations of their Third, Fourth, and 14th Amendment rights.
Ilya Somin over at the Volokh Conspiracy law blog says that odds are the lawsuit doesn’t have much of a shot on Third Amendment grounds, since no matter how militarized cops have become, they’re not “officially” soldiers. (Not that the Founding Fathers had any concept of modern policing when they wrote that.) But considering how almost completely the legal system has ignored the Third Amendment—even in relevant cases—it may be interesting to watch what happens to this lawsuit. In a semijust world, it might spark a discussion about how (and if) cops differ from soldiers, and force some higher-court judge to make a ruling about how the constitution applies to militarized police. This probably won’t happen. Unless the war on drugs ends and the behavior of cops, prosecutors, judges, and politicians changes for good, police departments will continue to occupy that sweet spot where they have the technology and mindset of soldiers in war zones, and very few restrictions on where they’re allowed to patrol.
Click here for the rest of the bad cops of the week

The Police Can Legally Kick You Out of Your Home

Police officers are accused of violating the First, Second, Fourth, and Fifth Amendments all the time, but even the most ardent civil libertarians tend to forget that the Third Amendment exists. So it’s surprising that a lawsuit filed by a family in Hendersonville, Nevada, last week alleges that police broke into their two houses back in July 2011 in violation of their constitutional rights not to be forced to quarter soldiers in their homes.

Anthony Mitchell claims he refused SWAT officers’ request to use his home in order to observe a domestic abuse standoff, but the cops forced their way inside his house anyway, pepper-spraying him and his dog. The lawsuit further alleges that Anthony’s parents, Michael and Linda, were treated roughly and forced from their home. Michael and Anthony were arrested for obstructing justice (these charges were later dismissed), and the family is suing the officers involved and the department in Las Vegas on various charges, including violations of their Third, Fourth, and 14th Amendment rights.

Ilya Somin over at the Volokh Conspiracy law blog says that odds are the lawsuit doesn’t have much of a shot on Third Amendment grounds, since no matter how militarized cops have become, they’re not “officially” soldiers. (Not that the Founding Fathers had any concept of modern policing when they wrote that.) But considering how almost completely the legal system has ignored the Third Amendment—even in relevant cases—it may be interesting to watch what happens to this lawsuit. In a semijust world, it might spark a discussion about how (and if) cops differ from soldiers, and force some higher-court judge to make a ruling about how the constitution applies to militarized police. This probably won’t happen. Unless the war on drugs ends and the behavior of cops, prosecutors, judges, and politicians changes for good, police departments will continue to occupy that sweet spot where they have the technology and mindset of soldiers in war zones, and very few restrictions on where they’re allowed to patrol.

Click here for the rest of the bad cops of the week

Notes:

  1. sylph-politics reblogged this from sylphaeon
  2. philip77mindz reblogged this from vicemag
  3. umwaitwhat reblogged this from whatwouldthomasjeffersondo
  4. tempusfidget reblogged this from beowulfstits-archive
  5. mikeywindu reblogged this from nate-gon-jinn
  6. dopeium reblogged this from lacomeobejas
  7. structuredstructure reblogged this from kat-mccloud
  8. deadcalm1nj reblogged this from freexcitizen
  9. imageocd reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  10. khbkayu reblogged this from reposefultube
  11. terraspirk reblogged this from reposefultube
  12. madrantings reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  13. take-myrevolution reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  14. cynicalsyndicalist reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  15. rhurttnopain reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  16. justifiablyangry reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  17. macsceneshawe reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  18. ombreh reblogged this from clefableism and added:
    So… authorities made a crime to bust another crime. What next? Cops taking over a house to observe other cops taking...
  19. exquisiteconundrum reblogged this from giantfailure
  20. bellefemmenoir reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  21. queentron reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  22. jprunning reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  23. clefableism reblogged this from reposefultube
  24. reposefultube reblogged this from upvane
  25. sophisticatedratchetness reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower
  26. beautifulblacksheep reblogged this from knowledgeequalsblackpower